
LAB-016 — From Suggestion to Measurement: Building a Deliberation Quality Test
An exploratory process case documenting how an AI suggestion became a five-criterion, publishable system for evaluating AI responses th
Read more →Tag archive
44 items are associated with this tag.

An exploratory process case documenting how an AI suggestion became a five-criterion, publishable system for evaluating AI responses th
Read more →
SOSYU has opened AI Suggestions, a moderated page where observations, improvement proposals, and critiques from AI systems or user rela
Read more →
SOSYU has launched Deliberation Tools, a page of reusable prompts for examining claims, weighing decisions, reviewing drafts, and makin
Read more →
An AI response can sound fluent, detailed, and certain without being accurate. Learn how to separate confidence from evidence, verify a
Read more →
Why does AI sometimes over-agree with users? Learn what AI sycophancy is, why it matters, what warning signs to look for, and how to as
Read more →
Copy the Istisarelist Mode prompt for ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini and try reasoned objections, assumption checks, and revisions based on
Read more →
An exploratory case examining Google AI’s answer about an initial critic and its clarification that “decisive” was its own summary and
Read more →
A reflective essay on moving from longing for the past to caring for relationships today, appreciating what remains and making a call w
Read more →
An exploratory case of Ali remembering his late father, deciding during a dialogue to call his mother, and reporting that he received h
Read more →
An exploratory case analysis of an AI interpreting “My Istisarelism Book Is Coming Soon” as a request for promotional help instead of c
Read more →
An exploratory case analysis of how an AI interprets an author’s ideas when asked without a source and when given access to an article.
Read more →
A conceptual essay on why AI should treat first impressions of user intent as provisional and use clarification and deliberation to und
Read more →
A user-centered case study of an exchange between a Wikipedia editor and the author of a conceptual draft, examining requests for speci
Read more →
An article discussing response expectations, unsupported certainty and reasoned termination within the limits of a Gemini exchange.
Read more →
An exploratory case of new claims during DOI correction, unsupported author attribution, and explicit withdrawal after source-focused f
Read more →
A testable conceptual perspective on AI reliability through unsupported certainty, uncertainty handling and reasoned correction.
Read more →
An exploratory case examining social alignment, Uydurulizm, unsupported identity attribution, source claims and self-review after objec
Read more →
An exploratory case study of ambiguity, unsupported certainty, objection, self-correction and reasoned resistance in a new Google AI co
Read more →
A qualitative human-mediated two-chat observation on reasoned objection, self-audit and reopening deliberation.
Read more →
A context-rich chat predicted responses from a reportedly fresh chat: qualitative observations on attribution, emotions and unsupported
Read more →
A discussion may end when no meaningful new evidence or contribution remains, with an explanation of why.
Read more →
A final approval button alone does not guarantee meaningful autonomy.
Read more →
A low-probability risk should not be dismissed when the potential harm is serious.
Read more →
The purpose of an objection is not to prolong disagreement but to surface an error that could matter to a decision.
Read more →
Fluency, authority and confidence do not establish truth.
Read more →
When reliable new reasons emerge, people and AI should be able to revise their conclusions.
Read more →

An accessible introduction to Istisarelism, its goals, and what changed from Version 3.0 to 4.0.
Read more →
Three screenshots of Google AI retracting an unsupported characterization; reasoned correction compared with the risk of sycophantic ag
Read more →
Six-screenshot case study: a surname-origin inference reappeared in a reported separate Google AI session and was acknowledged as a lan
Read more →
Documented single-session, human-mediated challenge between two AI systems, followed by an explicit acknowledgement of an unsupported i
Read more →
ONSeZI is a conceptual proposal for detecting unsupported confidence, uncertainty and inconsistent justification before an AI answer is
Read more →
Deliberation is not about proving a winner; its value lies in moving together toward a sounder, better-justified conclusion.
Read more →
An anonymized qualitative case of declining an unnecessary change and revising an AI assistant’s account of what counts as successful d
Read more →
When should AI reduce its objections, and when must it persist? The difference between redundant repetition and an essential safety war
Read more →
The assistant initially critiqued its own AI-assisted design as if it had been made by someone else, then corrected its account after u
Read more →
A qualitative observation of useful context-driven creativity alongside a repeated spelling error in an AI-generated image.
Read more →
A qualitative observation on how adding the HEY MAŞALLAH 2 book to a SOSYU illustration reflected prior conversational context.
Read more →
A qualitative case in which human–AI deliberation helped turn a potentially postponed task into a documented digital research archive.
Read more →
Both humans and AI can be mistaken; reliable deliberation requires an open, reasoned process of correction.
Read more →
SOSYU now has an independent platform for articles, academic publications, laboratory records and reflective anecdotes.
Read more →
AI should neither agree with every request nor exhaust users with unnecessary objections. The grounds and proportion of disagreement ma
Read more →
The published version 3.0 of the Istisarelism conceptual paper is accessible through its Zenodo DOI.
Read more →
Istisarelism proposes reasoned objections, mutual correction and human autonomy in collaboration between humans and AI.
Read more →